4.7.3 For Clauses

Most loops are governed by one or more for clauses. A for clause simultaneously describes variables to be bound, how those variables are to be stepped during the loop, and usually an end condition based on those variables.

The word as is a synonym for the word for. This word is followed by a variable name, then a word like from or across that describes the kind of iteration desired. In Common Lisp, the phrase being the sometimes precedes the type of iteration; in this package both being and the are optional. The word each is a synonym for the, and the word that follows it may be singular or plural: ‘for x being the elements of y’ or ‘for x being each element of y’. Which form you use is purely a matter of style.

The variable is bound around the loop as if by let:

(setq i 'happy)
(cl-loop for i from 1 to 10 do (do-something-with i))
i
     ⇒ happy

for var from expr1 to expr2 by expr3

This type of for clause creates a counting loop. Each of the three sub-terms is optional, though there must be at least one term so that the clause is marked as a counting clause.

The three expressions are the starting value, the ending value, and the step value, respectively, of the variable. The loop counts upwards by default (expr3 must be positive), from expr1 to expr2 inclusively. If you omit the from term, the loop counts from zero; if you omit the to term, the loop counts forever without stopping (unless stopped by some other loop clause, of course); if you omit the by term, the loop counts in steps of one.

You can replace the word from with upfrom or downfrom to indicate the direction of the loop. Likewise, you can replace to with upto or downto. For example, ‘for x from 5 downto 1’ executes five times with x taking on the integers from 5 down to 1 in turn. Also, you can replace to with below or above, which are like upto and downto respectively except that they are exclusive rather than inclusive limits:

(cl-loop for x to 10 collect x)
        ⇒ (0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10)
(cl-loop for x below 10 collect x)
        ⇒ (0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9)

The by value is always positive, even for downward-counting loops. Some sort of from value is required for downward loops; ‘for x downto 5’ is not a valid loop clause all by itself.

for var in list by function

This clause iterates var over all the elements of list, in turn. If you specify the by term, then function is used to traverse the list instead of cdr; it must be a function taking one argument. For example:

(cl-loop for x in '(1 2 3 4 5 6) collect (* x x))
        ⇒ (1 4 9 16 25 36)
(cl-loop for x in '(1 2 3 4 5 6) by 'cddr collect (* x x))
        ⇒ (1 9 25)

for var on list by function

This clause iterates var over all the cons cells of list.

(cl-loop for x on '(1 2 3 4) collect x)
        ⇒ ((1 2 3 4) (2 3 4) (3 4) (4))

With by, there is no real reason that the on expression must be a list. For example:

(cl-loop for x on first-animal by 'next-animal collect x)

where (next-animal x) takes an “animal” x and returns the next in the (assumed) sequence of animals, or nil if x was the last animal in the sequence.

for var in-ref list by function

This is like a regular in clause, but var becomes a setf-able “reference” onto the elements of the list rather than just a temporary variable. For example,

(cl-loop for x in-ref my-list do (cl-incf x))

increments every element of my-list in place. This clause is an extension to standard Common Lisp.

for var across array

This clause iterates var over all the elements of array, which may be a vector or a string.

(cl-loop for x across "aeiou"
         do (use-vowel (char-to-string x)))

for var across-ref array

This clause iterates over an array, with var a setf-able reference onto the elements; see in-ref above.

for var being the elements of sequence

This clause iterates over the elements of sequence, which may be a list, vector, or string. Since the type must be determined at run-time, this is somewhat less efficient than in or across. The clause may be followed by the additional term ‘using (index var2)’ to cause var2 to be bound to the successive indices (starting at 0) of the elements.

This clause type is taken from older versions of the loop macro, and is not present in modern Common Lisp. The ‘using (sequence …)’ term of the older macros is not supported.

for var being the elements of-ref sequence

This clause iterates over a sequence, with var a setf-able reference onto the elements; see in-ref above.

for var being the symbols [of obarray]

This clause iterates over symbols, either over all interned symbols or over all symbols in obarray. The loop is executed with var bound to each symbol in turn. The symbols are visited in an unspecified order.

As an example,

(cl-loop for sym being the symbols
         when (fboundp sym)
         when (string-match "^map" (symbol-name sym))
         collect sym)

returns a list of all the functions whose names begin with ‘map’.

The Common Lisp words external-symbols and present-symbols are also recognized but are equivalent to symbols in Emacs Lisp.

Due to a minor implementation restriction, it will not work to have more than one for clause iterating over symbols, hash tables, keymaps, overlays, or intervals in a given cl-loop. Fortunately, it would rarely if ever be useful to do so. It is valid to mix one of these types of clauses with other clauses like for … to or while.

for var being the hash-keys of hash-table

for var being the hash-values of hash-table

This clause iterates over the entries in hash-table with var bound to each key, or value. A ‘using’ clause can bind a second variable to the opposite part.

(cl-loop for k being the hash-keys of h
               using (hash-values v)
         do
         (message "key %S -> value %S" k v))

for var being the key-codes of keymap

for var being the key-bindings of keymap

This clause iterates over the entries in keymap. The iteration does not enter nested keymaps but does enter inherited (parent) keymaps. A using clause can access both the codes and the bindings together.

(cl-loop for c being the key-codes of (current-local-map)
               using (key-bindings b)
         do
         (message "key %S -> binding %S" c b))

for var being the key-seqs of keymap

This clause iterates over all key sequences defined by keymap and its nested keymaps, where var takes on values which are vectors. The strings or vectors are reused for each iteration, so you must copy them if you wish to keep them permanently. You can add a ‘using (key-bindings …)’ clause to get the command bindings as well.

for var being the overlays [of buffer] …

This clause iterates over the “overlays” of a buffer (the clause extents is synonymous with overlays). If the of term is omitted, the current buffer is used. This clause also accepts optional ‘from pos’ and ‘to pos’ terms, limiting the clause to overlays which overlap the specified region.

for var being the intervals [of buffer] …

This clause iterates over all intervals of a buffer with constant text properties. The variable var will be bound to conses of start and end positions, where one start position is always equal to the previous end position. The clause allows of, from, to, and property terms, where the latter term restricts the search to just the specified property. The of term may specify either a buffer or a string.

for var being the frames

This clause iterates over all Emacs frames. The clause screens is a synonym for frames. The frames are visited in next-frame order starting from selected-frame.

for var being the windows [of frame]

This clause iterates over the windows (in the Emacs sense) of the current frame, or of the specified frame. It visits windows in next-window order starting from selected-window (or frame-selected-window if you specify frame). This clause treats the minibuffer window in the same way as next-window does. For greater flexibility, consider using walk-windows instead.

for var being the buffers

This clause iterates over all buffers in Emacs. It is equivalent to ‘for var in (buffer-list)’.

for var = expr1 then expr2

This clause does a general iteration. The first time through the loop, var will be bound to expr1. On the second and successive iterations it will be set by evaluating expr2 (which may refer to the old value of var). For example, these two loops are effectively the same:

(cl-loop for x on my-list by 'cddr do …)
(cl-loop for x = my-list then (cddr x) while x do …)

Note that this type of for clause does not imply any sort of terminating condition; the above example combines it with a while clause to tell when to end the loop.

If you omit the then term, expr1 is used both for the initial setting and for successive settings:

(cl-loop for x = (random) when (> x 0) return x)

This loop keeps taking random numbers from the (random) function until it gets a positive one, which it then returns.

If you include several for clauses in a row, they are treated sequentially (as if by let* and setq). You can instead use the word and to link the clauses, in which case they are processed in parallel (as if by let and cl-psetq).

(cl-loop for x below 5 for y = nil then x collect (list x y))
        ⇒ ((0 nil) (1 1) (2 2) (3 3) (4 4))
(cl-loop for x below 5 and y = nil then x collect (list x y))
        ⇒ ((0 nil) (1 0) (2 1) (3 2) (4 3))

In the first loop, y is set based on the value of x that was just set by the previous clause; in the second loop, x and y are set simultaneously so y is set based on the value of x left over from the previous time through the loop.

Another feature of the cl-loop macro is destructuring, similar in concept to the destructuring provided by defmacro (see Argument Lists). The var part of any for clause can be given as a list of variables instead of a single variable. The values produced during loop execution must be lists; the values in the lists are stored in the corresponding variables.

(cl-loop for (x y) in '((2 3) (4 5) (6 7)) collect (+ x y))
        ⇒ (5 9 13)

In loop destructuring, if there are more values than variables the trailing values are ignored, and if there are more variables than values the trailing variables get the value nil. If nil is used as a variable name, the corresponding values are ignored. Destructuring may be nested, and dotted lists of variables like (x . y) are allowed, so for example to process an alist

(cl-loop for (key . value) in '((a . 1) (b . 2))
         collect value)
        ⇒ (1 2)